When I decided to invest in a high-quality rowing machine for my home workouts, I found myself comparing three top contenders: the Hydrow, Peloton Row, and Aviron. Each offered unique features and experiences, making the decision both exciting and challenging. Here’s a detailed breakdown of my journey to help you understand the differences and determine which might be the best fit for your fitness goals.
Design and Build Quality
Hydrow
The Hydrow immediately caught my attention with its sleek, modern design. Weighing in at 145 pounds, it felt sturdy and well-built. It supports users up to 375 pounds and accommodates inseams up to 36 inches, which was reassuring for my taller friends. The 22-inch HD touchscreen added a premium feel, enhancing the immersive experience.
Peloton Row
Peloton’s reputation for quality is evident in their rowing machine. The anodized and powder-coated aluminum frame felt durable, and at 156.5 pounds, it was solid without being cumbersome. It supports users up to 300 pounds and features a 23.8-inch swiveling HD touchscreen, perfect for those off-rower workouts.
Aviron
The Aviron Strong Series impressed me with its robust construction. Weighing 114 pounds, it supports users up to 507 pounds and accommodates heights up to 6’8″. The 22-inch rotating HD touchscreen was a nice touch, and the adjustable footplates ensured a comfortable fit. The design felt both functional and inviting.
Resistance Mechanism
Hydrow
I loved the computer-controlled electromagnetic resistance. It provided a smooth and quiet rowing experience, closely mimicking the feel of rowing on water. This feature made my workouts feel authentic and enjoyable, without the noise often associated with rowing machines.
Peloton Row
While specifics were a bit scarce, the electronic resistance felt smooth and quiet during my trial. It seemed designed for a seamless rowing experience, allowing me to focus on my form and the workout without distractions.
Aviron
The combination of air and magnetic resistance offered up to 100 pounds of resistance. This dual system provided a dynamic and engaging workout, keeping me on my toes. The slight breeze from the air resistance was a refreshing bonus during intense sessions.
Programming and Content
Hydrow
With over 4,000 instructor-led rowing workouts filmed on waterways worldwide, I felt like I was part of a global rowing community. The live and on-demand classes, scenic rows, and additional workouts like yoga and Pilates kept things fresh. The membership was $44 per month, which I found reasonable given the extensive content.
Peloton Row
The studio-style rowing classes were energetic and motivating. Features like Form Assist offered real-time feedback on my technique, which was invaluable. The All-Access membership matched Hydrow at $44 per month, providing a comprehensive fitness experience with various workout options.
Aviron
I was particularly drawn to the gamified workouts. The game-based programs, live competitions, and the ability to stream content from platforms like Netflix and YouTube made workouts feel less like a chore. The membership was more affordable at $29 per month, offering diverse content that kept me engaged.
Storage and Footprint
Hydrow
Measuring 86 inches long, 25 inches wide, and 47 inches high, it required a bit of space. However, it could be stored vertically with an additional upright storage kit, which was a plus for my apartment. This feature made it convenient to tuck away when not in use.
Peloton Row
At 96 inches long and 24 inches wide, it was the longest of the three. The folding mechanism for compact upright storage and the included Upright Wall Anchor made it more manageable. I appreciated the thoughtfulness in design for home use.
Aviron
The Strong Series measured 84 inches long, 27 inches wide, and 48 inches high and could be stored upright without additional mounts, making it convenient for tighter spaces. This feature was particularly appealing for those with limited room.
Price and Warranty
Hydrow
Priced at $2,495, it came with a 5-year frame warranty and 1-year on components, screen, and electronics. The investment felt justified given the quality and content offered.
Peloton Row
At $3,195, it was the most expensive. It offered a 5-year frame warranty and 1-year on screen, components, and labor. The higher price point reflected the brand’s reputation and the comprehensive fitness ecosystem.
Aviron
The Strong Series was priced at $2,199, making it the most budget-friendly. It came with a 10-year frame warranty and 1-year on parts. The combination of affordability and robust features made it a compelling choice.
Conclusion
After weighing all these factors, I found that each machine had its unique strengths:
- Hydrow: Perfect for those seeking an immersive, on-water rowing experience with high-quality instructor-led content.
- Peloton Row: Great for users who prefer studio-style classes and integration with Peloton’s ecosystem, along with advanced form feedback features.
- Aviron: Ideal for individuals looking for a gamified workout experience with diverse content options, including entertainment streaming.
In the end, I chose the Aviron for its engaging content and budget-friendly price. It made my workouts something to look forward to every day.
